Tasting Panel Summer 2017
Warm Weather Beers Part II: Saison vs. Saison

What is a saison?

Traditionally, saison is a rustic, artisanal ale made with local farm-grown ingredients, brewed for consumption during the active farming season in the French-speaking area of Belgium. Because these beers were made from whatever happened to be on hand, it was not unusual to have grains such as wheat, rye, oats, or spelt in the grist bill.
Sugar or honey could be added to provide complexity and dry out the flavour.
In North America, we often refer to saisons as farmhouse ales. This is the perfect beer to make during the summer months; see my Homebrew Happenin’s column for more about that.
– Warren Boyer

Our Judges

Our five volunteer beer experts are:

Warren Boyer, BJCP-Certified brewer & community leader

Mike Garson, aka Mike’s Craft Beer: an experienced beer event judge and tireless beer reviewer

Lynn McIlwee of Hops Canary: experienced beer event judge and homebrewer

Chelsea McDowell of Brewtiful BC: experienced beer event judge and homebrewer

Paul Pyne of DrinkSmarter: Certified Cicerone®, beer tutor, and good guy everybody knows by sight.

How judging is done

Our unsanctioned competition uses a Zagat-like 30-point rating with a weighted scale based loosely on the BJCP Scoresheet. Panellists are instructed to give an honest rating, not a sugar-coating. There is always something about each beer that at least one or two panelists with either like or dislike!

Appearance: 3 points

Aroma: 6 points

Palate (mouthfeel): 3 points

Flavour: 8 points

Overall Impression: 10 points

TOTAL: 30 POINTS

Note: neither What’s Brewing nor Legacy Liquor Store bear responsi­bility for the opinions expressed within, which are solely those of the individual panelists.

And the winner is:


We have a tie game! As seen below, both Four Winds and Strange Fellows averaged exactly 25 out of 30.

Bayard got the Panel’s only unanimous perfect ratings for Stylistic Accuracy and Appearance.

Meanwhile, La Maison scored highest for Flavour and Aroma.

Happily, all the beers did well this round.

 

The Results

Overall category results: Saison

First Pour

Enjoyment

Drinkability

Balance

Meet Jordan Knott, craft beer expert at Legacy Liquor Store

Got questions about craft beer? Talk to Jordan!

Legacy Liquor Store

1633 Manitoba St, Vancouver, BC
604.331.7900
info@legacyliquorstore.com

Online Order Desk
www.legacyliquorstore.com/shop

Disclaimer: What's Brewing does not make product recommendations. However, we can and do publish the opinions of our individual contributors. Our community panellists were instructed to give an honest rating, so don't expect a sugar-coating. Many thanks to all participating breweries!
Growler Cartoon Book